Skip to content
  1. Blog
  2. Mixing

MixingMasteringLoudnessBackground

The loudness war: why records kept getting louder, and why it stopped

Through the CD era, records were pushed louder and louder to stand out from the one before. Why the loudness war happened, well-known cases such as Metallica’s Death Magnetic, how loudness normalisation in broadcast and streaming changed things, and what it means for a mix today.

Written by the site’s operator4 min read
Compact discs
The loudness war was fought on CD. Every disc shared the same ceiling (0 dBFS), and that is where the race began.Photo: Dietmar Rabich / CC BY-SA 4.0 / Wikimedia Commons

Play an old CD and a new one back to back and the new one is far louder. Put their waveforms side by side and the new one is a solid block, filled from top to bottom.

That race to be louder is called the loudness war. In one line: records kept shaving down the difference between loud and quiet and raising the whole track, to sound louder than everything else.

Why louder seemed to win

Hearing has a bias: play the same song slightly louder and it tends to sound “better”. The lows and highs come through more and it feels more powerful.

  • In a CD changer or on the radio, the quieter track stands out. Nobody wanted to be the quiet one.
  • A CD has a hard ceiling (0 dBFS). With the same ceiling for everyone, the only way to sound louder is to hold the peaks down and raise the average.
  • The tools made it possible. From the mid-1990s, digital limiters that look ahead and catch peaks (sold as maximizers) came into wide use.

How much louder

Rock CDs in the 1980s are reported to have averaged around −17 dBFS. Oasis’s (What’s the Story) Morning Glory? in 1995 had many tracks averaging about −8 dBFS, exceptionally loud for its time. Same ceiling, an average close to 9 dB higher.

Raise the average and the gap between loud and quiet (the dynamics) shrinks. The thump of the kick, the lift as the chorus arrives, the breath in a quiet passage: loudness was bought with the song’s movement.

A famous case: Metallica’s Death Magnetic

Metallica’s 2008 album Death Magnetic is often held up as the symbol of the loudness war. Fans compared the CD with the versions of the same songs in the game Guitar Hero and found the CD far louder, and audibly more distorted.

A mastering engineer who compared them reported the CD as roughly 10 dB louder, and fans started a petition asking for a remaster. It was the moment many people learned that making a record louder can make it sound worse.

Louder does not mean it sells

The premise that louder sells was questioned too. A 2010 paper by Earl Vickers, presented at the Audio Engineering Society (AES) convention, questioned the assumption that loudness is strongly tied to listener preference and sales, and set out recommendations for de-escalating the race.

Heavily squashed audio may sound impressive for a moment, but it has also been linked to listening fatigue over longer periods.

Read next

Mixing

What a maximizer is: making a track louder, and why not too loud

A maximizer raises a track’s overall loudness while a limiter holds the peaks down. How it relates to a limiter, how streaming services even out volume (loudness normalisation), what −14 LUFS means, and the signs of pushing too far.

Mixing

Mastering basics: what happens after the mix

Mastering is the last step: turning a finished mix into something ready for streaming or CD. How it differs from mixing, the order of EQ, compression and limiting, streaming loudness (−14 LUFS, −1 dBTP), export formats, and how to approach a cover.

Mixing

What EQ Is: What to Cut, How Much, and Why

EQ is a volume control for each range of pitch. What you hear in the lows, mids and highs, why to start by cutting rather than boosting, what Q means, and what to try first on a vocal, with concrete frequencies.

Mixing

What a Compressor Is: Narrowing the Gap Between Loud and Quiet

A compressor turns down only what goes over a set level, evening out the volume. What threshold, ratio, attack, release and make-up gain mean, a starting point for vocals, and the signs of overdoing it.

Mixing

What reverb is: giving a voice a room to sit in

Reverb adds the reflections a room would give a sound. What pre-delay, early reflections and decay time mean, how room, hall and plate differ, why reverb goes on a send, and starting points for blending a cover vocal into a backing track.

Mixing

Where Does Harshness Live? Finding and Taming Piercing Frequencies

Most piercing sound comes from a very narrow peak somewhere around 2–5 kHz. Why hearing is so sensitive there, how to find the peak by sweeping a narrow EQ, how many spots and how much to cut, and how sibilance differs.

All articles

Sponsored links